March 17, 2025
The Angie Hammond Case
Unsolved mysteries are fascinating because they often leave so many questions unanswered. Our case this week embodies that perfectly. Coming out of Clinton, Missouri, this spine-chilling case involves a young woman who is abducted from a payphone by an unknown assailant and is never seen nor heard from again.
On the evening of Thursday, April 4, 1991, 20-year-old Angela “Angie” Hammond and her fiancé, Robert “Rob” Schafer made plans to meet up once Rob’s parents came home from a night out. In the meantime, Angie wanted to spend some time with her close friend, Kyla Angerman. She picked Kyla up from her home, and the two drove together around downtown Clinton. They spent a little more than an hour together before Angie decided to call it a night and dropped Kyla off at her home at approximately 11:15 p.m. Feeling exhausted, Angie wanted to head home to relax but knew she’d have to cancel her plans with Rob first. She didn’t have a cell phone, nor did she have a landline at home, so she stopped at one of two payphones located outside a nearby supermarket on 210 South 2nd St. At 11:23 p.m., Angie called Rob and talked to him for at least 15 minutes.
As the couple spoke, Angie began to express concern over a truck she saw circling the area around the gas station. She told Rob that she didn’t recognize it and couldn’t get a good look at the driver. When asked to describe the vehicle, Angie said it was a green 1960s-70s Ford pickup truck, with a decal of a fish jumping out of water covering the rear window. After giving this description to Rob, Angie saw the truck drive away, and the two went back to their conversation. However, it quickly returned, and this time, it pulled into the lot, causing Angie to express even more concern. A man got out and walked into the phone booth right next to her. A short time later, the man walked back to his truck and produced a flashlight, appearing to look for something inside the vehicle.
At this point, Angie described the man to Robas a dirty, Caucasian man with a beard and a mustache who wore overalls, a dark baseball-style hat, and black-rimmed glasses. After getting this description from Angie, Rob heard a sharp scream and shouted out to Angie but got no response. Instinctually, Rob bolted out of the house and into his truck before speeding to the phone booth. On the way to the payphone, he saw the headlights of a pickup truck coming towards him and heard a female’s voice scream “Robbie!!” as it passed him. Running on adrenaline, Rob quickly spun his truck around and slammed on the gas pedal to catch up to the truck. He was able to pursue the vehicle for approximately two miles, until his own truck stalled due to a damaged transmission. All he could do then was watch in horror as the truck and Angie disappeared into the night. Rob quickly notified the Clinton police, who later contacted the FBI for help after making no progress in their own investigation to find Angela. Thirty-four years have passed since her abduction, and the FBI has yet to locate Angela Hammond.
For more information on this case, refer to episode #61 of the Trace Evidence podcast wherever you get your podcasts.
If you have any information on the whereabouts of Angela Hammond, contact the Clinton Police Department at (800) 877-3452 or FBI at (800) 225-5324
—Seth VanEss, True Crime Editor